1. Coverage （10 points) A. Justified criteria for ...

1. Coverage (10 points) A. Justified criteria for inclusion and exclusion from review. 2. Synthesis (45 points) B. Distinguished what has been done in the field from what need to be done. C. Placed the topic or problem in the broader scholarly literature. D. Placed the research in the historical context of the field. E. Acquired and enhanced the subject vocabulary. F. Articulated important variables and phenomena relevant to the topic. G. Synthesized and gained a new perspective on the literature. 3. Methodology (15 points) H. Identified the main methodologies and research techniques that have been used in the field, and their advantages and disadvantages. I. Related ideas and theories in the field to research methodologies. 4. Significance (15 points) J. Rationalized the practical significance of the research problem. K. Rationalized the scholarly significance of the research problem. 5. Rhetoric (10 points) L. Was written with a coherent, clear structure that supported the review. 6. Intro to New Methods (5 points): M. Introduced new methods to address problems with predominant methods.